Start here
The honest one-line answer: if you already have your own 501(c)(3), use Givebutter. If you don’t, BrightLeaf Giving. They’re not at the same layer of the stack.
Givebutter is fundraising software for nonprofits that already exist. It runs donation pages, peer-to-peer campaigns, events, and CRM — but it doesn’t make you a charity. You need your own IRS-recognized 501(c)(3) to use it for tax-deductible giving. BrightLeaf Giving includes fiscal sponsorship in the box: an existing 501(c)(3) hosts your work, donations are tax-deductible from day one, and you skip the whole “form a nonprofit first” step.
The rest of this page is the honest comparison — where each one is the right fit, what each actually costs, and the one Givebutter detail that doesn’t show up in most reviews.
What each one actually is
Givebutter is a fundraising platform — donation forms, fundraising pages, peer-to-peer campaigns, event ticketing, a built-in donor CRM, and outreach tools. Stripe-backed payment processing. It’s free at the platform layer if you enable an optional tip-prompt for donors at checkout; if you disable tips, the platform charges 3% of each donation. To use it for tax-deductible giving, you connect it to your organization’s own 501(c)(3) — Givebutter doesn’t provide the charitable layer.
BrightLeaf Giving is a fundraising platform plus fiscal sponsorship. An existing 501(c)(3) — Rekonect for Community Support Funds and Social Impact Campaigns, Yeshiva Giving Fund for Education Opportunity Funds — hosts your work under its umbrella. Donations are tax-deductible from day one because the sponsor is the charity of record. You get donation pages, dashboards, recipient management, and disbursement workflow on top of the charitable structure. Full mechanics on the pillar page.
The distinction that matters: Givebutter is the tooling layer for a nonprofit you already are. BrightLeaf is the tooling and the nonprofit layer for a cause that needs both.
The fork — which stack do you need?
One question decides nearly everything: do you already have an IRS-recognized 501(c)(3)?
Givebutter is likely the right fit
You already have the charitable layer. What you need is software that runs your fundraising. Givebutter does this well, and the platform fee is genuinely $0 when donors are willing to tip.
You’d be using it for:
- Donation pages tied to your existing 501(c)(3)
- Peer-to-peer campaigns, events, recurring giving
- Built-in donor CRM and outreach tools
- Tip-funded model: $0 platform fee on most gifts
Doesn’t make you a charity. You bring the 501(c)(3); they bring the software.
BrightLeaf Giving is built for this
Fiscal sponsorship is included. An existing 501(c)(3) hosts your work, donations are tax-deductible from day one, and you skip the Form 1023 process plus the recurring overhead of running a nonprofit.
You’d be using it for:
- Memorial scholarships, community drives, relief efforts
- Hardship funds for a specific family or individual
- Tuition assistance and named scholarship funds
- Causes that need to launch in days, not the six-to-twelve months it takes to form a 501(c)(3)
Includes the charitable layer. We bring both the 501(c)(3) and the software.
For most operators searching this comparison, the question isn’t really “Givebutter vs. BrightLeaf.” It’s “do I form my own 501(c)(3) first, then use Givebutter — or do I use a fiscal sponsor that includes the structure?” We cover that math on the sponsor vs. your own 501(c)(3) page.
Where Givebutter wins
For an organization that already has its 501(c)(3), three honest advantages.
Platform fees can genuinely hit $0. When tips are enabled and donors are willing to tip, Givebutter doesn’t charge the nonprofit a platform fee — the platform is funded by the optional tips. The processing fees (2.9% + 30¢ on card, 1.9% + 30¢ on ACH) are passed through, and the Givebutter Guarantee covers any processing fees donors don’t cover. For a healthy donor base that’s culturally comfortable with the tip prompt, the math is genuinely good.
Broader feature surface. Givebutter ships peer-to-peer campaigns, event ticketing, a built-in donor CRM, email and SMS outreach, recurring giving, team pages, and a polished donor-facing experience with progress thermometers and social-share built in. BrightLeaf is purpose-built for the fund types it hosts (CSF, SIC, EOF) and intentionally narrower in feature scope. For a multi-program nonprofit running events, P2P drives, and an annual fund all in one tool, Givebutter has more breadth.
You stay in full control of your 501(c)(3). Funds go directly to your nonprofit’s account, you control disbursements without sponsor review, and you’re already filing the 990 anyway. For an established organization with operational capacity, the fiscal-sponsorship layer BrightLeaf provides is exactly the part you don’t need.
Where BrightLeaf Giving wins
For an operator who doesn’t have a 501(c)(3) and doesn’t want to spend six-to-twelve months and several thousand dollars building one, three structural advantages.
Tax-deductible donations from day one. Rekonect (CSF/SIC) or Yeshiva Giving Fund (EOF) is the 501(c)(3) of record. Donors get a tax receipt issued automatically when their gift completes, with the sponsor’s EIN. No “fundraiser tied to a personal account” loophole, no requirement that you eventually pay tax on the money raised. Real charitable receipting from day one, without forming anything.
Disbursements to individuals. Givebutter routes funds to your organization’s bank account; what you do from there is up to you and your organization’s policies. BrightLeaf’s sponsors release funds directly to recipients — a specific family, a student’s school, a vendor providing a service to the cause — under the project’s written charitable purpose. For Community Support Funds, scholarship funds, and relief efforts, that flexibility is the whole point of the structure.
Honest, all-in pricing — no tip-prompt mechanics. Fees are itemized: platform (tiered down by donation size), sponsor, processing, disbursement. Donors can opt in to cover them at checkout, but there’s no default 15% tip that gets routed away from the cause. The donor-facing experience says exactly what their gift accomplishes — not what platform tip they’re supporting on top.
Six scenarios, six right answers
Common situations, with the right call labeled for each.
“We’re a 501(c)(3) running an annual gala and a peer-to-peer campaign.”
Givebutter’s event ticketing and peer-to-peer tools are well-built, and if your donor base will tip, your platform cost is essentially zero. BrightLeaf doesn’t host P2P or events in the same way.
“I’m a private individual raising money to help a family in our community.”
A Community Support Fund. Without a 501(c)(3), Givebutter can’t make those donations tax-deductible — and disbursing to an individual family from your own organization’s bank account is a setup most nonprofits aren’t structured for. BrightLeaf does both pieces in one product.
“I’m starting a memorial scholarship in a relative’s name.”
An Education Opportunity Fund. Givebutter would require you to form a 501(c)(3) first — a process that takes six-to-twelve months and several thousand dollars in attorney and filing fees. EOF is built for exactly this case, with the scholarship-specific IRS compliance handled by Yeshiva Giving Fund.
“Our nonprofit needs to consolidate donations, events, and CRM in one tool.”
Multi-tool consolidation is genuinely Givebutter’s sweet spot. If you have the 501(c)(3) and want one platform for everything fundraising-adjacent, Givebutter is built for that. BrightLeaf’s scope is intentionally narrower.
“We’re a community group raising money for a one-time relief effort.”
A Social Impact Campaign. The cause is real, the urgency is real, but forming a 501(c)(3) for a one-time effort would be over-engineering. BrightLeaf gets you raising tax-deductible donations in days, not months.
“I’m an established 501(c)(3) but I run a very specific program that doesn’t really need general-purpose tools.”
If the program is a scholarship fund or a community fund for individual recipients and your existing nonprofit treats it as essentially a separate program — running an EOF or CSF on BrightLeaf alongside your main 501(c)(3) can be cleaner than building those workflows into Givebutter. For pure donation pages tied to your existing org, Givebutter is the better fit.
What it actually costs
Two important reads here: the headline numbers, and the all-in cost once you factor in whether you have a 501(c)(3) or are paying to build one.
Givebutter fees. Tips enabled: $0 platform fee for the nonprofit, processing pass-through (2.9% + 30¢ card, 1.9% + 30¢ ACH). The Givebutter Guarantee absorbs processing fees donors don’t cover. Tips disabled: 3% platform fee, same processing. Optional donor tip defaults to 15% — donors can edit or remove it during checkout. Tips go to Givebutter, not to your organization.
BrightLeaf fees (CSF/SIC). Platform tiered 6.5% → 3.5% per donation (gets cheaper as donations get larger), 2% to Rekonect as fiscal sponsor, processing pass-through (3.5% card, 1% ACH, 3% DAFPay), 2% disbursement on the way out. EOF runs notably lighter: 4.5% → 2.75% platform, 1% YGF sponsor, free ACH, 1% disbursement.
$50K raised by card, total cost comparison
Processing: ~$1,510 (2.9% + 30¢ per gift, assuming 200 gifts of $250).
Net to your nonprofit: ~$48,490.
Not shown: the cost of having a 501(c)(3) — Form 1023 filing, attorney fees, annual 990, state registrations, registered agent, insurance. Typically $2,000–$5,000/year in recurring overhead before this $50K runs through it.
Total on $50K (200 gifts): ~$44,000 to balance.
At disbursement: 2% Crowded = ~$880.
Net to cause: ~$43,120.
No 501(c)(3) overhead — it’s included.
If donors cover fees (the “donor covers both” toggle, ACH route): net to cause approaches ~$48,900.
The honest read: on this $50K example, Givebutter’s net-to-cause looks higher — if you already have a 501(c)(3). If you don’t, the cost of building and maintaining one (six-to-twelve months of formation work and $2,000–$5,000/year in recurring overhead) dwarfs anything on this table. BrightLeaf includes the structure in the rate.
The detail worth knowing — Givebutter’s default tip
Givebutter’s checkout, by default, prompts donors with a 15% tip that goes to Givebutter, not to your organization. Donors can edit it (down to any amount, including zero) or remove it during checkout. It’s clearly disclosed, and donors who pay attention can opt out — but the default landing point is 15%.
This is what makes Givebutter “free” for the nonprofit. The platform is funded by tips — every tipped donation effectively means the donor paid 115% of what they thought they were giving to your cause. For donors who understand and choose it, that’s fine. For donors who don’t read carefully, it means their gift was meaningfully smaller in cause-dollars than they intended, with the difference going to a software company rather than to your work.
The fair counter-point: a 15% optional tip is meaningfully different from a hidden percentage fee. Donors who do read the checkout can opt out. Plenty of nonprofits use Givebutter happily and their donors are fine with the model. We mention it only because most operators comparing platforms aren’t shown this prominently in marketing materials, and it’s the kind of detail worth knowing before deciding.
Questions people ask
Can I use Givebutter without a 501(c)(3)?
Not for tax-deductible giving. Givebutter is built around the assumption that the user is already a registered 501(c)(3); the platform itself doesn’t provide charitable status, doesn’t issue tax receipts under its own EIN for non-501(c)(3) campaigns, and doesn’t host fiscal sponsorship. If you don’t have a 501(c)(3) and you need donations to be tax-deductible, you need either a fiscal sponsor (like BrightLeaf) or to form your own 501(c)(3) first.
Is BrightLeaf cheaper than Givebutter?
On the donation-fee line alone, no — Givebutter’s tips-enabled model effectively makes the platform free for the nonprofit, while BrightLeaf charges a tiered platform fee, sponsor fee, and disbursement fee. But the comparison isn’t apples-to-apples: Givebutter requires you to have a 501(c)(3), and forming and maintaining one runs $2,000–$5,000+ per year in recurring overhead before any donation runs through it. For an organization without a 501(c)(3), BrightLeaf is usually substantially cheaper all-in. For an organization that already has one, Givebutter usually wins on the donation-fee line.
What’s the difference between Givebutter’s “tips” and BrightLeaf’s “donor covers fees” toggle?
Both let the donor pay extra so the organization keeps more — but the framing and recipient differ. Givebutter’s tip goes to Givebutter the software company (default 15%, editable). BrightLeaf’s “donor covers fees” toggle adds the actual processing, platform, or sponsor fees to the donor’s gift so 100% of the original donation amount reaches your fund — the extra goes to cover real costs, not to the platform. Same outcome (donor pays more, cause gets more); different relationship to where the extra dollars go.
Can I run an established nonprofit on BrightLeaf?
BrightLeaf is built around fiscal sponsorship — Rekonect or YGF holds the charitable status. An established 501(c)(3) wouldn’t move their full operations onto BrightLeaf (that would mean dissolving their own structure, which usually doesn’t make sense). What sometimes happens: an established nonprofit runs a specific program — a scholarship fund, a community-recipient fund — on BrightLeaf alongside their main operations, because the EOF or CSF structure fits that program better than building those workflows in-house.
Does BrightLeaf support peer-to-peer fundraising or events?
Social Impact Campaigns support team pages and goal tracking — the multi-donor, single-cause shape of P2P. Event ticketing in the Givebutter sense isn’t a primary BrightLeaf feature. For an organization whose fundraising shape is heavily P2P and event-driven, Givebutter (with a 501(c)(3)) is genuinely the better fit.
Can I switch from Givebutter to BrightLeaf or vice versa?
In one direction, easily. A BrightLeaf fund operator who later forms their own 501(c)(3) can move to Givebutter (or any other tooling-only platform) — BrightLeaf’s exit terms are written into the original agreement and handle outstanding funds and donor records. The other direction is rarer in practice: a 501(c)(3) on Givebutter usually doesn’t move to a fiscal sponsor unless they’re winding down their own entity for other reasons.
What to do next
Three doors in. Pick the one that fits where you are.